
Rubirosa: Pizza > Pasta, and Four Stars—No Longer Five
📍 235 Mulberry Street, Manhattan 🍕
🕰️ Open Daily: 11 AM – 11 PM
📞 (212) 965-0500 | Rubirosa NYC
TIE DYE™ pizza and warm bread pudding steal the show, while the pasta sits forgotten—delicious highs and forgettable lows in one stylish shot.
🍕 The TIE DYE™ Pizza—Not Quite Heaven on Earth, But Pretty Darn Close
Rubirosa isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a shrine for pizza disciples. Born of pizza royalty (AJ Pappalardo, son of Joe & Pat’s founder), this Nolita hotspot has been flipping pies since 2009.
And the pizza? Mama mia meets modern masterpiece.
📝 What We Ordered
Dish | Verdict | Notes |
---|---|---|
🔥 TIE DYE™ Pizza (vodka/tomato/pesto/mozzarella) Small $33 — up $5 in just a few months! 💸 |
✅ Hall of Fame | Light, crisp, perfectly balanced. A pizza ballet on your tongue. 💃🍕 |
🍯 Honey Pie (soppressata/spiced honey/fontina) Small $33 — because inflation comes with extra mozzarella. 🧀💸 |
🤷♂️ Good, but not great | Solid first time, but underwhelming on round two. Bring the heat, honey! 🍯🔥 |
🍕 The Classic Pie (Tomato, Mozzarella, Original Recipe) Small $29 |
✅ Solid OG | A nod to their Staten Island roots. A safe bet for any pizza purist. 🛡️ |
❌ Bucatini alla Nereno $32 |
💀 Pasta Crime | Too salty, somehow tasteless. Not special. Not again. Not ever. |
✅ Spaghetti alla Chitarra (Tomato/basil/parmigiano) |
😋 Only Pasta Worth It | The sauce saves it. The meatballs? Let’s just say… not the MVPs. ⚽ |
🥪 Meatball Parm Hero | 😐 Decent | But again… those meatballs need therapy. |
🍮 Tiramisu & Bread Pudding | 💘 Divine | Bread pudding > tiramisu. Fight us. 🥊🍞 |
🛑 Service? Oof.
Third visit, third time’s not the charm. Our reservation at Rubirosa NYC was for 11:45 AM. We arrived early, seated early.
But at 11:40 AM—yes, before we even hit the halfway mark:
“Just so you know, your table is reserved again at 1:00 PM.”
🤨 Wait, what?
Yes, we get it, you're busy. But telling us twice about the next booking before the food even arrives? Kills the vibe faster than bad gnocchi.
💸 Not Exactly Budget Pizza
Total incl. 3 small pies, 1 bad pasta, 1 desert (shared), and 1 latte: $174.72. It’s rather pricey. The first two visits? Totally worth it. But after a salty pasta and salty service… well, let’s just say four stars is generous.
For a cheaper yet wonderful alternative, check out Modern Apizza in New Haven, CT.
🍝 What To Try Next Time (If We’re Still Curious)
-
🍚 Mini Rice Balls – Mascarpone, prosciutto, fontina
-
🥓 Carbonara – Speck, egg yolk, scallions
🍰 Dessert Royalty
The bread pudding will ruin all future desserts for you.
Warm. Gooey. Fragrant. Melt-in-your-mouth bliss.
💯 Do not share. You’ll regret it.
🪑 The Rubirosa Setup
Three seating options:
1️⃣ High-top tables
2️⃣ Cozy bar seats
3️⃣ Regular dining room
✅ Good for dates, friends, family—if the timing gods are in your favor.
🥂 Pro Tips:
-
✅ Use Resy—this place books out fast.
-
⏳ Don’t linger—apparently they’ll remind you you’re on the clock.
-
📸 Tie Dye™ Pizza = Insta bait. (You're welcome.)
🏆 Grand Prize Winners
The TIE DYE™ Pizza and Bread Pudding.
Forget the pasta (okay, maybe keep the Spaghetti alla Chitarra—but skip the meatballs). Stick to what Rubirosa really nails: crispy, bold pizza and dessert glory. 🍕🍮
🔚 Final Slice:
We’ll return—but not right away. The NYC pizza scene is vast and legendary. Rubirosa's got the goods, but it’s no longer our GOAT.
💬 Been there? Got a better slice? Tell us or fight us (with bread pudding).
📛 Disclaimer:
We’re not food critics. We’re just adventure pilgrims wandering from shack to country, fork in hand and joy in heart. 🥄❤️
🧭 Want More Like This?
👉 Explore our Foodies Travel Hub for even more fun!
👉 Head over to our News & Perspectives with a Different Lens hub
👉 Browse our Funanc1al Wellness Hub for body insights with a wink and a plank
👉 Check our satirical finance series: “We the Spenders” (Coming soon)
👉 Or explore our Funanc1al Political Humor Roundup (if you dare to go deep, which we don't)
👀 Want to stay relevant (and entertained)?
📍 Visit Funanc1al.com — because we cover serious ideas with unserious emoji.
Other articles:
Quick links
Search
Privacy Policy
Refund Policy
Shipping Policy
Terms of Service
Contact us
About us
FUNanc!al distills the fun in finance and the finance in fun, makes news personal, and helps all reach happiness.
Got a thought? A tip? A tale? We’re all ears — drop it below.: